ISSN 2084–1418
The paper edition of the Anthropology of History Yearbook is the definitive version
2017, No. (10), Anthropology – Folklore – History
Elisabeth Morrow Clark
“Dzięki temu, ja jestem”: Memories and Narratives of Trauma and National Identity
![](http://rah.pth.net.pl/images/pdf-icon.png)
PDF version
Keywords: the modern history of Poland, post-memory, identity, national history, emigration, women's
Abstract: This paper analyzes the ways in which post-memory is manifested in these works and compares these to a series of interviews conducted by the author. It begins with a contemplation of Lawrence Langer's Holocaust Testimonies and a discussion of the ways in which Holocaust memory as a field can inform other post-memory and oral history studies. I then apply insights from Langer and from Ewa Hoffman's After Such Knowledge to the interviews which form the core of my research. These conversations about the experience of emigration and resettlement from the Kresy ("lost" regions of Poland after World War Two) offer insights into women's identities, personal and national. I also use Ewa Hoffman's Lost in Translation, a memoir about language, identity, place, and family. The author explores life and identity in postwar Poland and America questioning the larger forces which shaped her family's lives and revealing the inner forces which compelled her to integrate past generational traumas into her intellectual and social existences. I am particularly interested in how Hoffman addresses personal identity alongside ethnic and linguistic adaptations. In my interviews, I have asked a series of questions in order to determine the family experience of moving from the Kresy to the "tri-city" of Gdańsk/Gdynia/Sopot, what elements of the story are consistent in each generation, and the extent to which each generation self-identifies as Polish, as Gdańszczanin (Gdańsk residents), or as being from Wilno/Vilnius, Lwów/L'viv, or Pinsk, all regions from which families fled in the postwar era. This paper investigates the conflicts and the costs of emigration and expulsion, not just in immediate suffering, but in the playing-out of national, cultural, regional ethnic and personal identities. All the cases studied involve generational and post-memory elements. I am interested in exploring how families remain Polish, even after having to adopt a new, potentially non-Polish, regional home while losing the former home under traumatic circumstances. The undercurrent of the stories told by mothers and daughters, whether autobiographical or fictional, reveals the important role women play in maintaining family history and, by extension, national history and identity.
About Author:
ELIZABETH MORROW CLARK – historian, assistant professor at West Texas A&M University. E-mail: eclark[at]wtamu.edu
References
About the Project. 2009. Strona internetowa Veterans History Project. Dostęp: 14 kwiecień 2009. http://www.loc.gov/vets/about.html
About this Site: Learning Zone. Strona internetowa WW2 People’s War. Dostęp 15 maj 2009. http://www.bbc.co.uk/ww2peopleswar/about/lzone_family_cominghome.shtml
About this Site: The original idea. Strona internetowa WW2 People’s War. Dostęp 15 maj 2009. http://www.bbc.co.uk/ww2peopleswar/about/project_01.shtml
Brokaw, Tom. 1998. The Greatest Generation. New York: Random House, 1998. Citation from the “The Time of their Lives,” Chapter One, The Greatest Generation in the New York Times. Strona internetowa New York Times. Dostęp 10 czerwiec 2009. http://www.nytimes.com/books/first/b/brokaw-generation.html
“Debra A. Fisher, 45, interviewed by facilitator Karen Dimattia, 30, Recorded in New York City,” Listening is an Act of Love; A Celebration of American Life from the StoryCorps Project, Dave Isay, Editor, New York: Penguin Books, 2007. p 176.
Hirsch, Marianne. 1998. “The Generation of Postmemory.” Poetics Today 29 (1): 103-128.
Hirsch, Marianne i Leo Spitzer. 2006. “What’s Wrong with This Picture? Archival photographs in contemporary narratives.” Journal of Modern Jewish Studies 5 (2): 229-252.
Hoffman, Ewa. 2004. After Such Knowledge. New York: Public Affairs.
Hoffman, Eva. 1989. Lost in Translation. London: Random House.
Kostanecka (matka). 2009. Wywiad przeprowadzony 26 kwietnia.
LaCapra, Dominick. 1998. History and Memory after Auschwitz, New York: Cornell University Press.
Langer, Lawrence L. 1991. Holocaust testimonies: the ruins of memory. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Morrow 2009. Rozmowy prowadzone od 19 marca do 2 maja.
Orla-Bukowska (ciocia). 2009. Wywiad przeprowadzony 24 maja.
Readership WT Students, Auschwitz Memorial and Museum Workshop, March 2008.
Story Corps: The Conversation of a lifetime. Strona internetowa Story Corps. Dostęp 15 maj 2009. http://www.storycorps.org/.
William Wyler….
“William Wyler and His Screen Philosophy.” 1946. The New York Times, November 17. Strona internetowa New York Times. Dostęp 14 kwiecień 2009. http: www.nytimes.com/packages/html/movies/bestpictures/miniver-years-ar.html
Wyler, William, dir. 1946. The Best Years of our Lives. Samuel Goldwyn Company. Strona internetowa Internet Movie Database. Dostęp: 14 kwiecień 2009. http: www.imdb.com/title/tt0036868/quotes.
WW2 People’s War. Strona internetowa WW2 People’s War. Dostęp 13 maj 2009. http://www.bbc.co.uk/ww2peopleswar/